This Week in Fiction

Souvankham Thammavongsa on the Gears That Turn Underneath a Story

苏万卡姆·塔马冯萨谈故事底下运转的齿轮
The author discusses her story “Wall Cano.”
作者讨论她的短篇小说《墙火山》。
作者谈论她的短篇小说《墙上的卡诺》。
A photo of Souvankham Thammavongsa in red. The background has some cursive writing on a green background.
Illustration by The New Yorker; Source photograph by Steph Martyniuk

This week’s story, “Wall Cano,” opens: “Mom left. Dad didn’t tell us anything.” The narrator of the story is a ten-year-old girl who has been living with her parents and her younger brother in a small basement apartment until one morning, before school, her mother’s not there. Why did you want to start the story in such a direct way?

本周的小说《墙火山》开篇写道:“妈妈走了。爸爸什么都没告诉我们。”故事的叙述者是一个十岁的女孩,她和父母、弟弟住在一间狭小的半地下公寓里,直到一天早上,上学之前,她发现母亲不在了。你为什么想用这样直接的方式开头?

I was thinking of writing a poem—just a list of my father’s smiles. But then I began to build in things around the list of smiles I had. A window. Cardboard. I really played around with the arrangement of the story. I felt like I could begin the story anywhere, put it out of order, and no matter how I arranged the details the story remained the same. Mom left. So I began with that.

我本来想写一首诗——只是列一份我父亲各种笑容的清单。但后来我开始在那些笑容清单的周围搭建一些东西。一扇窗。纸板。我确实在故事的编排上反复摆弄。我觉得这个故事从哪儿开始都行,打乱顺序也没关系,不管我怎么安排细节,故事本身都不会变。妈妈走了。所以我就从那里开始。

The narrator’s father is a stylish man. He’s short, she says, but he has suits made up by a tailor that fit him perfectly. It’s clear that her mother is attractive, too. Other women are always trying to get the father’s attention and other men the mother’s. Does the narrator feel as though it was her job to keep them together?

叙述者的父亲是个讲究穿着的人。她说他个子矮,但他有裁缝量身定做的西装,穿在身上严丝合缝。很明显,她的母亲也很有魅力。别的女人总想引起父亲的注意,别的男人也总想引起母亲的注意。叙述者是否觉得,维系他们俩在一起是她的责任?

I think she just thinks of it as normal. This keeping them together. It isn’t any different to her than being told to tie her shoe or eat breakfast.

我觉得她只是把这当成一件正常的事。维系他们在一起。这对她来说,和被要求系鞋带或者吃早饭没什么两样。

At one point, the narrator’s father tells her that he never got to go to school. In Laos, where he grew up, “the war came, and that was it.” The narrator is left to figure things out by herself, and she often gets it wrong. The concept of homework, for example, is something she can’t understand. If school is the equivalent of work, then surely time at home is for relaxing after work. How hard is it for her to puzzle her way through a life her parents never experienced?

有一处,叙述者的父亲告诉她,他从来没有上过学。在他长大的老挝,“战争来了,一切就结束了。”叙述者只能靠自己摸索,而且经常弄错。比如“家庭作业”这个概念,她就无法理解。如果上学等同于工作,那么在家里的时间当然就是工作之后用来放松的。她要靠自己拼凑出一条父母从未经历过的生活道路,这有多难?

When I write, I know that the room reads me—or the voice on the page reads me—as someone who will tell a sad story. It’s a real surprise for people to discover that the way they have read my sentences in their head is not the same as experiencing my sentences live—in my own voice. I think of my stories as being built around humor. Maybe not laugh-out-loud humor, though that’s there, but other forms of humor like wit, deadpan, understatement, exaggeration, recognition, irony. We know what homework is, but the way the story asks us to suspend our understanding of homework for a bit to live in hers is funny. Doing it this way doesn’t diminish or judge or humiliate her lived experience. I love who I come from and where I come from. When I tell a story, I make sure a reader does that, too.

我写作的时候,知道房间在解读我——或者说纸上的声音在解读我——把我当成一个会讲悲伤故事的人。人们真正感到意外的是,他们在脑海中读我句子的方式,和我亲口朗读这些句子的体验并不一样。我认为我的故事是围绕幽默搭建的。也许不是让人捧腹大笑的幽默,虽然那种也有,但更多是其他形式的幽默:机锋、冷面、轻描淡写、夸张、会心一笑、反讽。我们都知道家庭作业是什么,但故事要求我们暂时搁置自己对家庭作业的理解,进入她的理解中去生活一会儿,这本身就很好笑。用这种方式来写,并没有贬低、评判或羞辱她的生活经验。我爱我的出身,我爱我来自的地方。我讲故事的时候,会确保读者也能做到这一点。

She does know that she’s supposed to make something for a science project, but she’s forgotten about it in the weeks after her mother left. Her father helps her make something, pulling down some of the cardboard that they use on the windows in place of curtains. What he makes—a model of a house on stilts, like one he’d lived in in Laos—is beautiful, but when she gets to school, she realizes that it’s completely wrong. Does she feel worse for herself or for her father?

她确实知道自己该为科学课做一个东西,但母亲离开后的几周里,她把这件事忘得一干二净。父亲帮她做,扯下一些他们用来代替窗帘糊在窗户上的纸板。他做出来的东西——一个高脚屋的模型,就像他以前在老挝住过的那种——很漂亮,但到了学校,她意识到这东西完全不对。她更替自己难过,还是更替父亲难过?

I think she thinks everyone else is wrong. It’s a lot like that song Dolly Parton wrote, “Coat of Many Colors”: everyone else at school might think it’s a coat made of rags, but to her it is still a coat and it was made by her mother with what they had around the house. To build a house and make it stand is a science project, too. It might not win anything, but you don’t have to win anything to know that what you made deserves to live in this world.

我觉得她认为其他人都错了。这很像多莉·帕顿写的那首歌《百衲衣》:学校里其他人可能觉得那只是一件破布拼成的外套,但对她来说,那仍然是一件外套,而且是母亲用家里现有的东西做的。盖一座房子并让它立起来,这也是一项科学项目。它也许赢不了任何奖,但你不需要赢得任何奖,才知道你做出来的东西配得上活在这个世界上。

The project that wins—and that gives the story its title—is a model of a volcano, a word she hears as “wall cano.” It’s ugly, like “a pile of shit,” she thinks, but impressive when smoke comes out of a hole. As in other of your stories, such as “How to Pronounce Knife,” the title story of your 2020 collection, English is the language your characters must use to navigate the world outside the home, but any mistakes, like pronouncing “knife” with an audible “k,” convey a kind of glorious defiance, too. Would the narrator ever think of the “wall cano” as a volcano?

最终获胜的项目——也是小说标题的由来——是一个火山模型,她把“volcano”听成了“wall cano”。那东西很丑,像“一坨屎”,她想,但当烟从洞里冒出来时,却令人印象深刻。就像你其他小说里写的那样,比如你2020年小说集《如何念“刀”》的同名篇,英语是你的角色在家庭之外的世界里必须使用的语言,但任何错误,比如把“knife”里的“k”念出声来,同时也传递出一种光荣的反抗。叙述者会不会有一天把“wall cano”想成火山?

I write about language. I ask us to pretend the English language right in front of us is not there. This is very easy to understand when we read a work and are told it is a translation. We are made to understand our distance from the English language. I write that distance into the English language in front of us with the English language. We all know we don’t pronounce the “k” in “knife.” It’s something we have learned—to see a letter there and agree that even though it is right there in front of us we will not give it a sound. And yet, in the telling, we are made to wonder, When did we agree to this and why did we agree to this? We understand why someone new to the language would question this. Instead of focussing on the “mistake” someone new to the language makes, we don’t see it as a mistake at all, but see that it makes absolute sense. I do a similar thing here, but with a different word. This time, though, I never give the correct word. We remain isolated with the word “wall cano,” and remain in her perspective and point of view and understanding of the language. We live and move through the story the way her father knows the English language. He says, “I just poo-poo paa-paa my way around until something makes sense to them. That’s how English works.” We do what he says of the English language—we, the readers, are given the responsibility of carrying the meaning and understanding of these words.

我写的是语言。我要求我们假装眼前的英语并不存在。当我们读一部作品并被告知它是翻译的时候,这一点很容易理解。我们被引导着意识到自己与英语之间的距离。我把这种距离用英语本身写进了眼前的英语里。我们都知道“knife”里的“k”不发音。这是我们学到的东西——看见那里有一个字母,然后一致同意,尽管它就在眼前,我们也不给它任何声音。然而,在讲述的过程中,我们被引导着去想:我们是什么时候同意这一点的?为什么同意?我们理解为什么一个刚接触这门语言的人会对此提出质疑。我们不再聚焦于语言新手所犯的“错误”,而是根本不把它看作错误,反而看到它完全讲得通。我在这里做了类似的事,只是换了一个词。不过这一次,我始终没有给出正确的词。我们始终被隔离在“wall cano”这个词里,停留在她的视角、她的观点和她对语言的理解之中。我们在这个故事里生活和穿行,就像她父亲使用英语的方式一样。他说:“我就是噗噗啪啪地乱说一通,直到他们听明白为止。英语就是这么回事。”我们照着他说的方式对待英语——我们这些读者,被赋予了承载这些词语意义和理解的责任。

At the end of the story, the time frame shifts, and the narrator is now a thirty-seven-year-old woman, visiting a friend and watching as she checks her son’s homework. Why did you want to explicitly switch into this adult perspective?

在小说的结尾,时间框架发生了转换,叙述者现在是一个三十七岁的女人,去朋友家做客,看着朋友检查儿子的家庭作业。你为什么想明确切换到成年人的视角?

My stories come across as really simple and tiny. Breathe and the story is over already. Blink and it’s done. There are all these gears turning underneath the story that make it tick. I can’t draw attention to all that in the telling, because it would betray the telling of it. I could have certainly done this a different way. I could have had the child go over to another child’s house and discover that their parents helped with their homework, too. Take a reader into a scene where she discovers she doesn’t have what other people have. I could have had this moment come out in a discussion between her and her brother. But I don’t think she could really know how significant the story she just told is. It also feels too easy and cheap and sentimental to keep her that age and have her realize hers is a different experience. I needed a lot of life to happen for her. And there’s a lot of life between that science project and her friend’s house. And I need that life to happen in order to give significant weight to the story that has just been told. The refusal, even as an adult, to say the word “volcano.” That restraint, that absence there in the last scene, is so important to the story.

我的小说给人的感觉非常简单、非常小。喘口气,故事就结束了。眨个眼,就完了。但在故事底下,有无数齿轮在转动,让它滴答作响。我不能在讲述中把这一切都指出来,因为那会破坏讲述本身。我当然可以用另一种方式来处理。我可以让这个孩子去另一个孩子家里,发现他们的父母也帮忙辅导作业。把读者带进一个场景,让她发现自己没有别人拥有的东西。我也可以让这个时刻在她和弟弟的对话中浮现出来。但我不认为她真的能明白自己刚刚讲的那个故事有多重要。让她停留在那个年纪,然后让她意识到自己的经历与众不同,这也太容易、太廉价、太煽情了。我需要她经历很多很多生活。从那个科学项目到朋友家之间,隔着大量的生活。我需要那些生活发生,才能给刚刚讲完的故事赋予足够的分量。即使成年之后,她仍然拒绝说出“火山”这个词。那种克制,最后那个场景中的缺席,对这篇小说至关重要。

Do you think of this as a story about education? What’s more valuable to your narrator? What she learns from watching her father, her mother, and her brother, or what she learns in school?

你认为这是一个关于教育的故事吗?对你的叙述者来说,什么更有价值?是她从观察父亲、母亲和弟弟中学到的东西,还是她在学校里学到的东西?

I think of this as a story about love. People leave or they change, and no one is coming to make things better. You will have to learn to love yourself even when there is no one there to tell you that you’re worth loving. In a way, that is what an education is. You learn how to teach people how to love something until they can do that on their own without you. ♦

我认为这是一个关于爱的故事。人会离开,人会改变,没有人会来让一切变好。你必须学会爱自己,即使没有人在身边告诉你,你值得被爱。从某种意义上说,教育就是这样一回事。你学会如何教会别人去爱一样东西,直到他们能够不靠你、自己做到为止。♦

2 free previews left — register to get 30 translations a month